New York, NY 10011
Village Voice's Description
After multiple fizzled relationships with chefs, starting in 1998, Donatella Arpaia has finally seized the reins herself--and the food is fantastic. This is not just a Naples-style pizzeria, but a full-blown Italian restaurant, with the scope of the menu similar to what you might find in an Italian roadside osteria. The secret emphasis is on Sicilian fare, including a stunning pasta con sarde --in this case matching a thick spaghetti with fresh sardines and bread crumbs. The pizzas, too, are wonderful, and the very short list includes the usual margherita and marinara--both fine--though our fave is the diavolo, featuring spicy salami and chile oil.
Tips from foursquare
This spot's an ode to everything Neapolitan, w/ a 5-ton, gold tiled pizza oven built by hand completely out of materials imported from Italy that gets so hot it can pump out the pies in 60-90 seconds.
Is the boss here? If so, flag her down and she’ll be nice to you. Otherwise, get her namesake pie, and the Diavolo.
Sponsored Tip: Order San Pellegrino or Acqua Panna water at Donatella Arpaia’s Neapolitan spot and a donation will be made to Share Our Strength!
Donatella Arpaia is cooking up authentic Neapolitan cuisine, like wood-fired pizzas and classic pastas.
Donatella Arpaia is cooking up authentic Neapolitan cuisine, like wood-fired pizzas and classic pastas at Donatella's in New York, NY. Find more tips at FN Local.
More Pizza Restaurants in New York
Reviews and News
The Trianon, of Naples, Italy This past Thursday, Fork in the Road put up a pizza quiz in which we offered photos of 10 margherita... More on Donatella Pizzeria »
Donatella Arpaia has given birth to more than one little miracle in the past few weeks. For one, she has a brand-new baby boy. She also... More on Donatella Pizzeria »
The founder of Nitehawk Cinema lobbied the state the allow movie theaters to serve alcohol and successfully: Gov. Andrew M. Cuomo signed... More on Donatella Pizzeria »