• Top Places
  • All
0 Ratings
+ Share On... Facebook Twitter

City Hall Restaurant

Map & Directions 131 Duane St.
New York, NY 10013


Village Voice's Description

Anything that swims is recommended at this Wall Streeteras hangout that seeks to re-create the (mainly imaginary) two-fisted eating halls of yesteryear. The trio of barrel herring--creamed, onioned, and carawayed--is so striking you can ignore the dull potato salad in the middle. Pan roasts, raw oysters, shrimp cocktails, and, especially, she-crab soup were all flawless, as was the touted burger, much too good for its garnish of iceberg and wooden supermarket tomato. Skip the low-on-flavor lamb saddle and signature Delmonico steakaunimproved by its mantle of blue cheeseain favor of any of the daily grilled fish.

Member Reviews

No Reviews yet, leave the first one below!

Your Review:

Your Rating:


Tips from foursquare

  • Lunch menu spans from the burger ($16), a blend of short rib and brisket served on a homemade onion bun, to Delmonico steak ($42), a dry-aged rib eye topped with a dollop of Iowa's Maytag blue cheese.

  • Peter S. on 01/09/10

    Order the raw seafood tower for 2 or 4 - It's spectacular.

  • Neil J. on 11/10/09

    best hamburger in NY

  • Siri 🌼. on 07/11/11

    The service is incredible. The food was amazing! Its got a nice vibe to it...definitely a classy place for a lunch in. The chef is super friendly as well as the staff.

  • amNewYork on 10/25/11

    This is the go-to power-lunching spot for top city officials. On the menu: oysters on the half shell; Ahi ginger tuna burger, a nice selection of entree salads and classic surf-and-turf dishes.

Check out City Hall Restaurant on Foursquare


More Steakhouse Restaurants in New York

See More Steakhouse Restaurants in New York

Reviews and News


More American Restaurants

Today's Daily Deal

E-Cigarette Ultra Kit ($50 value) View more Voice Daily Deals

Events Nearby

Restaurants Nearby

See More Restaurants